Skin Care Ingredient Profile: Dimethicone
What is it?
Dimethicones are unmodified silicones. Wellthat rather sounds pretty harmless. But what does that mean to you and I?
According to one manufacturer, unmodified silicones stay on or near the surface of the skin, producing an occlusive effect. Basically, manufacturers claim that this alone makes dimethicone safe because the molecules are too large to physically enter your body beyond the upper living cells.
There are also claims that Dimethicone associates with the upper layer of drying skin, and these molecules seem to display an aversion to both the water and proteins inside cells. This sounds very plausible, and probably an interesting premise to draw a conclusion that dimethicone is probably pretty harmless.
What is it supposed to do for my skin?
Well, here is the good, the bad, and the ugly of the skin care industry.
Silicone emollients demonstrate occlusive properties. Companies claim that this wonderful benefit traps moisture to the upper layers of skin, thus increasing a moisturizers effectiveness.
Ok, sure, I’ll bite that one-- What exactly is an occlusive property?I happen to know, having been a skin and hair care professional in years past to put myself through school where I studied a few years of chemistry and biology.
In reality, dimethicones form a layer on the skin which retains anything and everything beneath it, including impurities, sebum, and bacteria, as well as water. Logically, this would be the reason you want wash thoroughly BEFORE you apply anything with such a property
Essentially if you use a product with this silicone based product, you have just lathered a layer of plastic on your skin. Now if you are into body wraps, I guess that’s exciting. I am just not certain about this whole trapping moisture next to my skin. It’s a great thought, but something about lathering plastic wrap on my face day after day is somewhat disconcerting.
This “barrier” as skin care manufacturers like to call it, sloughs off as the skin renews itself, requiring frequent application to maintain results.
I am not sure what results we are to expect with an occlusive emollient…but do people really believe that dimethicones are going to help your stave off old age, wrinkles, and lines? Anyways…occlusive properties also means clogged pores - leading to pimples, bumps, and blackheads. At least that’s been my experience. If you are an adult around the age of 30 and started to use anti-aging products… and have experienced a sudden onset of acne… chances are, you may be enjoying the full scale benefit of dimethicone… and a potential side effect.
Dimethicones are also used in numerous hair products. It is used to coat the surface of hair and lubricate it, improving combing and detangling, and thus reducing hair loss and breakage. Dimethicone is frequently used in smoothing serums and anti-frizz serums.
Whenever I used a dimethicone based product on my hair, (like a conditioner) Imust wash my body thoroughly AFTER thoroughly rinsing my hair or risk enjoying occlusive properties on sensitive skin and waking up the next day covered in lovely pimples.
Skin doesn’t need chemicals to look healthy it needs natural care and feeding, along with gentle cleansing.Feeding your skin on the inside AND on the outside is the sure way to beautiful skin. In other words, there really isn’t a truly solid reason to use dimethicone in your beauty regimen, even if you have dry skin.
Potential Side Effects?
Studies prove that prolonged exposure of the skin to sweat, impurities, and bacteria, by occlusion, causes skin irritation. In other words using dimethicone may lead to:
• Pores becoming clogged, and/or potential allergic reactions.
If you have sensitive skin, acne-prone skin or allergic skin occlusive emollients probably will aggravate your situation.
Are there Safety Concerns?
According to several research websites, the following are known tumor promoters and also tend to accumulate in the liver and lymph nodes.
• Dimethicone
• Dimethicone Copolyol
• Cyclomethicone
Hmmm interesting. And the manufacturers tell us that silicone molecules cannot possible be absorbed by our bodies
There is evidence which indicates silicone is toxic to the human body. Perhaps you could tell me how a chemical can’t be absorbed by our bodies, but still be considered a toxic substance if ingested or injected?
According to www.ewg.org, there is Insufficient toxicity data to know if dimethicone is safe for use in cosmetics the data used to determine safety levels come from a related chemical. Wow, that is reassuring. But this tends to happen frequently. Like testing your brother’s IQ and granting you automatic genius status because his IQ went through the roof.
Side note: silicones are non-biodegradable, leading to negative environmental impacts, both during the manufacturing process and the disposal process. This in itself for me, both personally and professionally, is another major reason NOT to use this ingredient.
On basis that the little has been found on dimethicone and diemthicone copolyol, they have come to the conclusion that these products do not show ANY negative impact on our health, according to one independent study.
However, these methicones and their side effects (especially long-use effects) actually have not been studied closely. If you happen to know otherwise, I would love to see both the studies and the results of those studies.
With the little information derived on the chemical group of “methicones” (i.e. “phenyl trimethicone”, “dimethicone”, “dimethiconol”, dimethicone copolyol” and “cyclomethicone”) they seem to be very heavily used in the cosmetics industry. Methicones are found in many beauty products and their impacts with regard to health should be investigated more closely.
Still don’t believe silicone based substances are toxic? http://www.medical-library.net/sites/framer.html?/sites/_silicone_implant_disease.html
One of the more interesting controversies is whether or not silicone is harmful. If we are going to look at skin care ingredients, we need to consider potential health issues surrounding the ingredient. Regardless what you believe the fact is, your skin DOES draw from the ingredients you put on.
So we have potentially established the following:
• toxicity level hasn’t been actually determined or established for this exact chemical
• there aren’t a great number of studies publicized concerning the safety of methicone based products
• it is a non-biodegradable chemical
• Its occlusive properties can potentially HARM your skin, even if it eventually sloughs off.
• Although claims that unmodified silicone molecules cannot enter your body, we see cases of silicone toxicity and allergic-like reactions to silicone based products
What products contain this ingredient?
Currently, the EWG cites 1669 products to contain dimethicone.
Should I avoid it?
Dimethicones have been known to cause allergic reactions. Silicone itself has been proven to be toxic in the right levels. Considering dimethicone’s occlusive properties - If you have sensitive or reactive skin, I recommend that you consider eliminating this silicone derived chemical from your skin care regimen.
14 comments:
very true. i broke out from that stuff as a primer.
OMG- I am so in love with you right now.
I have had a sneaky suspicion for about a year that my anti frizz silk therapy hair product is causing a breakout on my cheeks and jawline- where my hair falls.
my dermatologist told me yesterday that i need antibiotice and birth control- but i really think it's the dimethicone!
1- do you know of a hair product that i can use for the frizzys on the side of my face, 2- do you have any reccs for skincare- i have discovered dimethicone in my current line as well (cosmedicine).
HELP.
Heather.Doss@gmail.com
I too have difficulty with silicone based products. Sometimes I develop pimples within hours of applying a cream or serum, other times it takes a few days. The main thing I notice is that they seem to increase blackheads as well as cause me very deep, painful pimples. There is a whole list of ingredients I have determined I can't use because they seem to clog my pores. I have been using a product line called Mastey that is silicone free and works well for me. They have hair and skin care products. Great article!
I know this article is old but I wanted to leave my comment in case someone else stumbles upon it looking for information about dimethicone too.
Whenever I used Biosilk Silk Therapy my scalp got incredibly flaky and itchy. Ignoring the symptoms, I continued to use it because I like the shine it gave my hair. Eventually, the itching became too bad so I switched to another silk product thinking perhaps Biosilk was the problem, not a specific ingredient.
I used Glossing Polish by Silk Elements. Soon after I developed a horrendous itchy rash behind both my ears. I tried to get rid of the rash but it would just flake off and reform. I often tuck my hair behind my ears so I quickly figured out the rash came from the hair product. Less than two days after I stopped using the silk product the rash started clearing up. Within four days the rash was completely gone.
Not rocket science or a huge mystery here. Two different brands, same core ingredients, similar skin irritation issues.
I regret that I cannot use dimethicone products anymore because I really like them, but not at the expense of my health and enduring skin irritations. It's like loving chocolate but being allergic to it. You want to eat it but you know you cannot.
Not sure that dimethicone is the culprit with the shampoos - could be SLS's (sodium lauryl sulfates) which is a known irritant. Check out this blog: www.hairlossbuddy.com/20/sodium-lauryl-sulfate
Don't be so quick to judge on this one... I suffer from extremely dry skin and the occasional bout of eczema, and dimethicone is the only product which provides me relief (Trust me, I've tried everything). Without it my whole body resembles a dandruff-ridden scalp.
If you have dry skin, it might just be your saviour!
I also know that this article is old, but I would like to say that I never had skin issues until dimethicone became common in make-up and lotions. It caused my skin to become itchy, red, swollen, and drier with every use. After four years of frustration with the red, tight itchy patch of skin I called my face, I went to a dermatologist who told me I was allergic to fragrances and probably had excema. He prescribed a product with high concentrations of dimethicone and, needless to say, my skin condition got worse. I finally sat down with all of my beauty products and listed all of the ingredients in each one. After a few products it became pretty clear that they all had one common ingredient- dimethicone. I threw those away and started using a basic combo of grapeseed and almond oil as a moisturiser. Today, I don't have a patchy, red, swollen face and don't have to hide behind cover-up or heavy foundation. It's too bad even our dermatologists won't admit that this stuff is bad for you. Read labels because it is in everything!
The fourth result of a Google search for "dimethicone toxicity" is this review of dimethicone tests on animals, in which the Cosmetic Ingredient Review Expert Panel concluded that it's safe:
Final report on the safety assessment of dimethiconeThe Cosmetic Ingredient Review is an industry-funded group that is supposedly independent from its commercial sponsors. Nonetheless, Christopher's explanation of dimethicone's "occlusive properties" has convinced me to avoid the stuff.
I've had nothing but issues my entire life with flaking and redness/irritation all over my face. Once I found that cleansing my skin with a salicylic acid product (I use St Ives salicylic acid face scrub), flushing the skin clean afterwards with water, then after pat-drying with a clean white cloth (my thing to see if anything is coming off afterwards), using Moisturel as a facial moisturizer. I've tried so many others, and Moisturel is the only one that has very little other contaminants for skins that are easily clogged such as petrolatum and mineral oil. The dimethicone in it is a great polymer protector. Otherwise, I would be going with a dimethicone-free product of the same type like one of the billions out there designed for sensitive skin. I've experimented with most (obviously not all), and the trend is always once petrolatum (or other thick pore clogging products such as that) are high in the ingredient list then the worst happens. Heck, if my skin ever has any redness, I can spot it with Moisturel and it goes away in 10-15 minutes.
I'm 34 years old, and I've been experimenting scientifically with this since I was 13.
I'm glad I found this page. It's a nice thorough explanation. I have very sensitive skin, and am normally very picky about what products I use. Recently, I made the mistake of buying a sample bottle of Aveeno daily moisturizer and put it on my hands and arms without reading the ingredients since I use some of their other products and they had been ok. It started to sting immediately! I tried to rinse some of it off and then read the ingredients. The dimethicone jumped right out at me. I vaguely remembered it being in some silicone based lubricant I had tried maybe 6 years ago, which of course had irritated my skin too. OMG! If you have sensitive skin, I must recommend avoiding all silicone based lubricants! It felt like irritating grease that doesn't really wash off. ...in my crotch! So, how long do I have to wait for this crap to naturally slough off my arms and hands??? That is so gross!!!
OMG! I suffer from horrible cystic acne that began in my late 20s. I have recently learned about the possibility of dimethicone being a contributing factor and your post just sealed the deal. I thought I was being so careful choosing non-comedogenic moisturizers but sure enough I looked and there it is. Do you have any suggestions for a dimethicone free daily moisturizer? And thank you so much for writing this.
unfortunately, dimethicone is very common. You will need an organic/all natural moisturizer that is also oil free. This is like finding a needle in a haystack.
Because of this, I am at the final stages for formulating an amazing serum/moisturizer that is dimethicone free and also is good for acne prone skin.
If you email us at info@christopherdrummond.com, we can get some samples for you to try out. The product will be ready in full size very soon...
www.christopherdrummond.com
[color=#d00002]Great blog! I haven't landed on blog.christopherdrummond.com before in my searches!I found very useful information about
[/color] [url=http://nuscin-online.info]akne[/url] [color=#d00002]here... Keep up the great work![/color]
Although old article I can't agree more. I was already aware of the bad effects of dimethicone when I read your post, but this just sealed the deal.
Regrettably there is a lot of manufactors which use the stuff, it has become so difficult to find a moisterizer without it, that now I just use an 100% pure almond oil for moistiring agent. Since then I've had no problems whatsoever. Although.... I THINk that Nuxe is selling an eco-oriented beauty skincare series without those bad "stuffies"
Post a Comment